Demolition of Boat shed – Landscape works

Council has advised that the boat shed will be demolished indicating the boat shed is now past its useful life. It is unfortunate that this community asset will not be replaced.

Merrimac high school have no option but to end their sailing program on LHM that has been in place the best part of the last 30 years.

Demolition/Landscape works planned for November have now been scheduled for January. The challenge now is to complete works in one of the highest rainfall months of the year, on top of El Nina prediction without any adverse effects on the lake.

Below is the landscape plan supplied by GCCC.


Old Photos Confirm Original LHM

Old images dating back to 1967 confirm an existence of a lake in the current LHM location. The tracks in the area match the current path of roads adjacent the LHM including Rio Vista Bvd and Barrier Reef drive.

The photo shows a sandy lake – the absence of any creeks or inflows into the lake add weight to the statements made by engineers involved with the construction of Lake
Hugh Muntz that it was built on a spring fed area.

The last photo shows LHM originally designed as freshwater lake completely isolated from any canal system. A far cry from the current situation where salt water enters the lake over 20 times a year not including flood peaks!

Algae Update

Council have issued an Amber alert on the 23rd of November for elevated levels of algae yet the latest graph indicates algae levels tracking well below closure level. The graph does not display toxin levels which may be the cause for the alert.

As a result of the ongoing El Nina, rainfall continues to fall well above average for this time of year. It is inevitable that with the extra rain, increased nutrients will be washed into the lake. In a healthy lake, submerged vegetation competes with algae for nutrients. The significant loss of submerged vegetation in LHM means more nutrients available for the algae and an increased risk of algal blooms.

As the current Phoslock treatment has no effect on nutrients entering the catchment, clearly substantial planting of submerged vegetation is important for reductions in algae and the long term health of the lake.

As we head into the summer storm season, we need to rely on the beneficial aspects of El Nina – increased flushing of algae through the overflow and increased cloud cover restricting algal growth to get through summer without closure.



Significant Submerged Aquatic Planting Mandatory For Lake Recovery

At the recent community info session, Alluvium consultants highlighted the importance of submerged aquatic vegetation not only in removing nutrients from the water but a necessity in overall lake health. This vegetation typically grows below the 2ft water depth.

In 2013 substantial loss of vegetation occurred as a result of a significant rise in lake salt levels and has struggled to return with the trend in salt increasing. Council have indicated that existing salt tolerant plants will eventually make up for the loss. 8 years on, there is very little evidence of this along the shoreline.

The recent improvement in water clarity has confirmed that since 2013, very little vegetation has returned to the key transition zone between the shallow and deep water.

As this area receives the most light, vegetation has the best chance of survival during algal blooms and reductions in water visibility during rain events. In relation to the west side of the lake, where the majority of the lake is too deep to support vegetation,  ONLY the shallow areas are suitable for growth. With the west side having high nutrient load and practically zero vegetation, planting is a necessity.

The option to replant areas of the lake with species effective in nutrient removal rated highly in the options report.

In formulating the LHM Management Plan, Council need to include widespread planting of salt tolerant plants to assist the current limited vegetation along with salt water management to ensure substantial plant losses do not occur in the future.


Council Clarification Over Salty Groundwater.

Received a call from the Head Engineer Steve Mc Veigh today to clarify the concern over the conflicting information in the salt water data.

He advised that the data displayed was a limited graphical representation of the changes in salt hence the confusion over the timing of tides. Steven confirmed that underlying data that Griffith analysed confirmed groundwater tidal influence from the canal.

In relation to improved monitoring of salt inputs, the difficulty of monitoring was confirmed but given the trend of increasing salt and the negative effects, a clearer understanding is required.

Concern Over Griffith Determination of Salty Groundwater

In the recent meeting in regard to fitting a one-way valve, Griffith responded in the meeting minutes by stating;

  • The data from the vertical profiler indicated there is a direct link to tidal patterns in both the deeper sections and the upper sections of the lake and the blocking of the exchange pipe would not reduce saltwater inflow due to this direct link.

The diagram below shows the profiler data and the variations in salt levels – Griffith are stating these changes relate to tide levels showing significant groundwater input pushed in by the tides.

Unfortunately these assumptions ARE INCORRECT!

If you break down the data into days you can see that the peaks occur at THE SAME TIME EVERY DAY. See daily lines on diagram.

Tidal patterns advance by approximately 1 hour every day so if these variations were related to tidal variations they would occur at different times of the day but they do not!


The result is that Griffith have not progressed further and investigated the influence of the canal and ran modelling on the effects.

The result is that the review of the one-way valve by Alluvium has been compromised by not just misleading but incorrect data and assumptions.

The fact that Alluvium highlighted only medium confidence in their review due to no modelling if a further indication of a compromised assessment.

So where is the evidence of significant groundwater?

The Care Group have requested clarification over these important findings and will advise if these observations are correct.

Please see link to minutes of Meeting – Minutes

Lake Ready for the Swimming Season with Low Algae Levels

On the back of favourable weather conditions as a result of La Niña, Algae levels have continued to remain relatively low through winter into spring. Typically a spike in Algae has occurred during this time. It is too early to see any positive effects from the Phoslock Treatment in August but water clarity has definitely improved.

Only time will tell if the success of treatment is compromised by high inputs of nutrients from the canal and the catchment as we head towards Summer.


Ongoing Requests for Griffith to Clarify Significant Groundwater Inflow

Griffith University have indicated groundwater as a significant source of saline inflow. Although impossible to measure the extent or even the concentration of any groundwater, ongoing in-lake measurements clearly indicate substantial inflows of salt from the canal having an impact. See diagram.

At the recent meeting with Council, the Care Group requested investigation into all inputs into the lake and to clarify the readings that indicate this salt input. Regardless of where the salt is coming from, the increasing trend in salt means more salt is entering the lake than exiting. Reducing a major input of salt from the canal has the potential to reduce the overall salt content of the lake and reduce stratification and lake decline.

The Griffith report 3 years ago highlighted the need for further information stating;

“More information on inflows is needed, both in terms of nutrient concentrations and volumes of water input from the storm water drains, as well as exchange of groundwater and/or the adjacent canal. An understanding of the source of the higher salinity water accumulating in the lake bottom is needed.”

Unfortunately 3 years on, Council has not taken steps to investigate and provide the  necessary information/monitoring to determine the detrimental effects from the canal.

The key questions are;

  • How can Griffith make a determination of significant groundwater without even assessing input from the canal in both tidal and rain events?
  • Are Council planning to effectively monitor salt, flow and nutrients from the canal to assist in this determination?

The Care Group will advise on the reply once received.

Request for Missed Options to be Included In Assesment

The Alluvium report unfortunately did not include the option that provides mixing of bottom waters near the lake exit pipe that was discussed at initial meeting with Consultants.

This option has the potential to reduce both salt and high nutrient levels in lake so well worth consideration and assessment by Alluvium. Both are major issues.

As highlighted, there is no perfect option but to not take steps on these issues will only result in the continual decline in water quality. Below is the link to the proposal.

Option For Consideration – Mixing Near Lake Exit

Lake Options Report Released

The options report is now available on the Council Website. Link included below.

The key to any report is the follow-up with action to address the key issues affecting the long term health of the lake. The Care Group will be looking forward to the plan to implement the best options to address the ongoing trend of increasing stratification and increasing salt that is has been a major contributor to the decline in water quality.

The one way valve did not score as well as expected – Alluvium only had medium confidence in their assessment given the minimal evidence and no modelling. Despite the significant influence the canal input has on both the salt and nutrient levels, there has been no assessment, investigation or modelling to determine how this input effects the lake.

Given the importance, the Care Group request that proper investigation including modelling be carried out on canal input.

Alluvium Lake Options Report